The constructive criticism thread.

Okay firstly I'd like to say sorry to any moderators if this is considered a hate thread or something that could become one. And if this is a dupe.

Okay. Well I know you all would like your say on what bands you don't like but without it being labeled as "hate" I know in band threads you're allowed to say constructive criticism but you get shot down a lot for it. So I decided to make this thread. What you do is say what band you're not too fond of and why.

Stuff you say is:
I don't like band name here because I think they're not being themselves and they don't actually play their own instruments. The way they could fix that would be to prove they play their own instruments and be themselves and relaxed a bit more.

(or whatever reason you don't like how they do things and how it could be fixed)

Things NOT to say is stuff like:
I hate band name here like oh em gee they don't play their own instruments how slack is that? I hope they die.

Please bear in mind this is a constructive criticism thread and not a hate thread.

One again I apologize to mods if this is considered a hate thread or will provoke others into posting hate.

Argh:

I know in band threads you're allowed to say constructive crittercism but you get shot down a lot for it.

Thing is, you would probably get shot down here, too.
Or someone could say something about a certain band, and a fan of that band may take it the wrong way, and yeah.
I just see something like this causing controversy or something.

But uh, I don't have anything to say in this thread. I've still yet to find a band I dislike.

Halloween:

Argh:

I know in band threads you're allowed to say constructive crittercism but you get shot down a lot for it.

Thing is, you would probably get shot down here, too.
Or someone could say something about a certain band, and a fan of that band may take it the wrong way, and yeah.
I just see something like this causing controversy or something.

But uh, I don't have anything to say in this thread. I've still yet to find a band I dislike.

yeah, I agree >.< Some people over analyse things and take comments FAR to seriously...

Viva La Mhairi:

Doesnt this get covered in the rules?

Well...

Rules:

2. any topics about not liking a band...

There's that, but this isn't specifically saying "This is a thread for expressing how much you don't like some band".

Rules:

7. Saying ... "HATE (unless it happens to be constructive criticism, with a point o-o)!" in every thread is spam and shouldn't happen. K?

This is for 'constructive criticism', but I still stick by what I said before:

Rules:

and respect other peoples taste... or try to.

Yeah, even if that's in the rules, it sometimes doesn't stop people from posting disrespectful comments about others' posts.

Uh. Yeah. So I don't know.

Alternatively you could just post constructive criticism on the indivdual bands' thread like you're supposed to do.